skip to main content skip to footer


Dinner Menu

Monday - Friday 3 pm - 10 pm
Saturday & Sunday 2 pm - 10 pm

Monday - Friday 3 pm - 10 pm
Saturday & Sunday 2 pm - 10 pm


Sharing Plates

$10.00Nana's Sausage Rolls

A blend of Irish sausage and spices rolled in a puff pastry and baked. Served with our famous hot mustard.

$8.00Connemara Salmon Dip

House smoked salmon dip blended with cream cheese, red onions, scallions, horseradish, lemon and sriracha. Served with naan bread and crackers.

$8.00Craic Garlic Chips

Steak fries topped with creamy garlic sauce and Irish cheddar.

$9.00Farmhouse Spuds

Fried potato skins with bacon, caramelized onion, cheddar jack cheese, sriracha, scallions & sour cream.

$11.00Connor's Wings

Chicken wings fried and tossed your style. Served with celery, carrots and bleu cheese or ranch.

Toss your wings & tenders!
Buffalo • Whiskey Glaze • Korean Chili• Sriracha Ranch • Peruvian • Jerk Rub

$9.00Karen's Scotch Egg

Lightly crusted gourmet sausage wrapped around a boiled egg. Served over champ potatoes, hot  mustard and demi gravy.

$9.00Sarah's Tenders

Beer battered all natural chicken tossed in your favorite sauce. Served with bleu cheese or ranch.

Toss your wings & tenders!
Buffalo • Whiskey Glaze • Korean Chili• Sriracha Ranch • Peruvian • Jerk Rub

$5.00Cinotti's Pub Pretzel

Freshly baked Cinotti's unsalted pretzel served with our famous hot mustard.
Add Beer Cheese  + 1

$10.00Lynda's Reuben Rolls

Two crispy wontons stuffed with Thumann's gourmet corned beef, sauerkraut and swiss with our famous hot mustard

Pub Classics

Add Culhane's Salad +3.5

Sweet Shepherd's Pie

Ground Certified Angus Beef ®, carrots, onions and peas stewed in our sweet Guinness demi gravy. Topped with whipped potatoes.
Regular 14  | Skinny 11
Add Cheddar Cheese +1

Banger's N' Mash

Gourmet Irish sausages served over garlic whipped potatoes and caramelized onion demi gravy.
Regular 14 | Skinny 11

$15.00Guinness Beef Stew

Certified Angus Beef® braised in Guinness, slow cooked with barley, baby portobello mushrooms, carrots, onions and diced potatoes in savory demi gravy.

*Guy Fieri's Favorite!

$10.00Kaye's Pasta Mac

Cavatappi pasta tossed in a garlic, sherry cream, cheddar, goat cheese, and Parmesan.
Add Shrimp, Natural Chicken +5

$16.00Kearney's Corned Beef N' Cabbage

Thumann’s gourmet corned beef brisket marinated in Guinness, slow roasted with herbs. Served with champ, sautéed cabbage, onions, and bacon.

Pint Sandwiches

Served with Steak Fries or Old Bay Coleslaw
Add Culhane's Salad +3.5

SLAP On Extra Toppings: 
Swiss |  Bleu Cheese Crumbles | Cheddar | Mushrooms |  Caramelized Onions +1 | Irish Cheddar +1.5 | Applewood Smoked Bacon +2 | Smash Avocado +2

$11.00Dirty Slapper Burger

Certified Angus Beef ® burger served on a Cinotti's bun with lettuce, tomato and onions.

Sub with Blackened/Grilled Natural Chicken

$12.00Drunken Cheesesteak

Thinly sliced beef marinated in Guinness, and sautéed with onions, peppers, mushrooms and cheddar on Cinotti's hoagie.

Sub with Natural Chicken - No Charge

Award Winning Eats!

$13.00Blarney Lamb Sliders

House seasoned gourmet American lamb served with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and a side of curry aioli.
Temp Medium & Up.

Guy Fieri's "Mac Daddy" Fav!

$11.00Leeann's Kickin Sandwich

Southern fried breaded chicken breast topped with Swiss, house-made pickles, truffle garlic mayo served on a Cinotti's potato bun.

Available with Natural Grilled/ Blackened Chicken

$13.00Munster Reuben

Thumann's gourmet corned beef with sauerkraut, Swiss, and thousand island on Cinotti's thick marble rye.
Lean Natural Corned Beef - No MSG!

$13.00The Ole' Smokey

House smoked Certified Angus Beef® brisket, cheddar cheese, old bay coleslaw served on a Cinotti's roll.

Soups & Greens

Salad Dressings: Ranch | Bleu Cheese| Sisters Vinaigrette | Garlic Balsamic | Oil & Vinegar |Apple Vinaigrette 

Add Grilled/ Blackened Natural Chicken or Shrimp +5  or Salmon +7

$7.00Sisters Salad

Crisp romaine, Parmesan, cherry tomatoes, croutons, house dressing

$8.00Culhanes Salad

Blend of baby lettuce, blended cheese, cherry tomatoes, red onion and house
croutons. Served with choice of dressing

$10.00Soup and Salad

Cup of soup with choice of Sister's Salad or Culhane's Salad

$11.00Avocado Cobb Salad

Romaine lettuce, fresh avocado, hard boiled egg, bleu cheese crumbles, Applewood smoked bacon, tomatoes and choice of dressing.

Kitty's Potato & Leek Soup

"Happiness is Homemade"

Bowl 6 | Cup 4

$7.00Crock O' Stew

A "wee" version of our famous Guinness Beef Stew!

Guy Fieri's Favorite!

Fisherman's Catch

Seafood locally sourced from Beaver Street Fisheries and Mayport C & C.

All natural, premium grade, hand trimmed the old fashion way.

Add Culhane's Salad to any entree  +3.5

$11.00Duval Cod Wrap

Blackened cod, lettuce, tomato, red onion, cheddar jack cheese, garlic aioli in a herb wrap. Served with steak fries or Old Bay coleslaw

$15.00Chads' Shrimp N' Grits

Fresh shrimp sautéed with tomatoes, mushrooms, and spicy garlic Parmesan sauce. Served with cheddar grits and scallions. 

Locals' Favorite!

Whiskey Salmon

Whiskey glazed Atlantic salmon with a choice of two sides: Saffron Rice, Garlic Champ Potatoes, Vegetable, or Cabbage. Blackened or Grilled

$15.00Dingle Fish Pie

Fresh cod, salmon,  shrimp, potatoes and peas in a Parmesan cream sauce. Encrusted with cheddar cheese and served with toast points.

Guy Fieri's Favorite!

$16.00Kyle's Fish N' Chips

North Atlantic cod filets, beer battered and fried golden brown. Served with steak fries, tartar, old bay coleslaw and lemon wedge.


"Seven-course Irish meal? Six pints and a potato."

$3.00Old Bay Coleslaw

$4.00Garlic Champ Potatoes

$4.00Steak Fries

$4.00Sauteed Cabbage, Bacon N' Onions

$4.00Jasmine Rice

$4.00Seasonal Vegetables

$4.00Cheddar Grits

$6.00Pasta Mac & Cheese



Served with vanilla ice cream

$6.00MJ's Brownie

$6.00Paddy's Bread Pudding

$6.00Johnny's Apple Saucers


For the Wee Folk (ages 10 and under)

Kid's Dessert

Add on to any Kids Meal

$1.95Vanilla Ice Cream

Served with Whipped Cream & Topped with Chocolate or Caramel Sauce.

$1.95Cinotti's Donut


Kid's Dinner

Includes choice of soda!

$5.95Crock O' Shepard's Pie

$5.95Atlantic Cod Fingers

$5.95Grilled Cheese Sammy

$5.95All Natural Chicken Tenders

$5.95Peanut Butter & Jelly Sammy

$5.95Mac N' Cheese

$5.95Leprechaun Cheeseburger

sisters 1998.jpg